freenode

← digests

IETF protocol threads: SCITT receipt gap, mail attribution, TLS codepoints

Internet & Protocols2026-11-22

Protocol work on 22 November clustered on authentication gaps and post-quantum sizing. Several working groups also opened or continued last calls on authorization and routing drafts.

RFC 9942 inclusion receipts leave tree size unauthenticated

Discussion on the SCITT list identified that RFC 9942 inclusion receipts do not authenticate tree size or leaf index. Those values sit in the unprotected header, so an altered size can still verify against the signed root. Implementers of transparency receipts should treat that as a verification hole until the specification or implementations close it.

Dispatch considers an Agent-of header for AI-generated mail

The IETF dispatch list debated a draft Agent-of header meant to attribute AI-generated email. Participants discussed how verification would work with DKIM and how delegation would be expressed. The thread is early proposal work, not a deployed header.

TLS codepoint request overlaps an adopted hybrid draft

TLS working group participants objected to a SignatureScheme code point request in draft-beck-tls-hybrid-codepoints. They said the non-working-group draft duplicates assignments already covered by the adopted draft-ietf-tls-composite-mldsa. The dispute is about registry hygiene, not a new signature algorithm.

LAMPS debates making one-signature certificate binding critical

The LAMPS list discussed whether the binding extension in one-signature-certs-04 must be marked critical. The concern is that a non-critical binding could leave long-lived certificates that cannot be revoked in the intended way. No consensus outcome is recorded in the thread summary.

EMU weighs fragmentation for post-quantum EAP-AKA

The EMU working group discussed fragmentation for post-quantum attributes and large SUCIs in draft-ietf-emu-pqc-eapaka-02. Participants noted that RFC 9048 would need an update to carry those larger objects. The issue is packet size, not a new authentication method.

LAKE last call on EDHOC lightweight authorization

Working group last call is open on draft-ietf-lake-authz-08, which specifies EDHOC-based lightweight authorization, with a stated end date of 22 September 2026. Reviews were mostly supportive, with minor technical objections. The draft is the authorization companion to the lightweight authenticated key exchange used in constrained networks.

Independent Go RPKI relying party Haetae announced

An independent Go RPKI relying party named Haetae was announced on SIDROPS, covering ASPA, RTR version 2, and CCR. A short follow-up touched on LLM-assisted development and whether its output matches rpki-client. Operators gain another implementation to compare against existing relying parties.

IDR last call extends OTC checks to route-server clients

Working group last call opened on draft-ietf-idr-otc-rs-verification, running from 20 November 2026 to 4 December 2026. The change is a minor extension of RFC 9234 that adds route-server client Only-to-Customer checks. Early messages showed support.